Termination with Cause
A Termination With Cause clause is a contractual provision that allows one or both parties to terminate the agreement due to the occurrence of specific circumstances or events that constitute a material breach or default by the other party.
Key elements of a well-drafted Termination With Cause clause:
- Definition of Cause: Clearly specifying the events or circumstances that constitute grounds for termination, such as non-payment, breach of representations or warranties, violation of laws or regulations, or failure to perform material obligations.
- Notice and Cure Period: Establishing procedures for providing written notice of the alleged breach or default, and allowing a reasonable opportunity for the defaulting party to cure or remedy the situation before termination becomes effective.
- Effective Date of Termination: Defining when the termination becomes effective, considering any cure periods, notice requirements, or wind-down arrangements.
- Termination Consequences: Outlining the rights, obligations, and potential liabilities of each party upon termination, such as payment of outstanding fees, return of proprietary materials, or post-termination obligations.
- Dispute Resolution: Including mechanisms for resolving disputes related to the alleged breach or the termination itself, such as negotiation, mediation, or arbitration.
Termination With Cause clauses are crucial in various types of contracts involving significant obligations, risks, or potential losses, where a material breach or default by one party may severely impact the other party's interests. Examples:
- Software Licensing Agreement: "If either party materially breaches any term of this Agreement and fails to cure such breach within thirty (30) days after receipt of written notice, the non-breaching party may terminate this Agreement immediately upon further written notice."
- Distribution Agreement: "In the event of a material breach of this Agreement by either party, the non-breaching party shall provide written notice specifying the nature of the breach. If the breaching party fails to cure the material breach within sixty (60) days after receipt of such notice, the non-breaching party may terminate this Agreement effective immediately."
- Employment Agreement: "The Company may terminate the Employee's employment for Cause, which shall include, but not be limited to, gross negligence, willful misconduct, material breach of this Agreement, or violation of Company policies. In the event of termination for Cause, the Employee shall not be entitled to any severance or additional compensation."
When reviewing a Termination With Cause clause, a contract drafter should be aware of:
- Clear and Objective Definitions: Ensuring that the definition of "cause" is clear, objective, and not subject to ambiguous or subjective interpretations, to avoid potential disputes or legal challenges.
- Adequacy of Notice and Cure Periods: Assessing whether the notice and cure periods provided are reasonable and sufficient to allow for potential remediation before termination becomes effective.
- Termination Consequences: Carefully evaluating the consequences and potential liabilities associated with termination, such as outstanding payment obligations, post-termination restrictions, or intellectual property ownership implications.
- Interaction with Other Clauses: Analyzing how the Termination With Cause clause interacts with other provisions, such as limitation of liability, indemnification, or non-compete clauses, to ensure consistency and mitigate potential conflicts.
- Governing Laws and Enforceability: Ensuring that the clause complies with applicable laws and regulations, and that the termination grounds and procedures are legally enforceable in the relevant jurisdiction.
Other closely related clauses that contract drafters should consider in conjunction with the Termination With Cause clause include:
- Termination Without Cause: Provisions outlining the rights and procedures for terminating the agreement without stating a specific cause or breach.
- Material Breach: Clauses defining what constitutes a material breach or default under the agreement, which may trigger the Termination With Cause clause.
- Limitation of Liability: Provisions limiting the parties' liability for damages or losses related to termination, subject to exceptions for willful misconduct or gross negligence.
- Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation: Clauses restricting the parties' ability to engage in certain competitive activities or solicit employees or customers after termination.
A famous example of a legal dispute arising from an incomplete or ambiguous Termination With Cause clause is the case of Walia v. Veritas Healthcare Solutions, LLC (2015). In this case, the court found that the employment agreement's Termination With Cause clause was ambiguous and failed to provide adequate notice or an opportunity to cure the alleged breaches. The court ruled that the termination was improper and awarded the employee substantial damages. (Citation: Walia v. Veritas Healthcare Solutions, LLC, No. 14-11366, 2015 WL 5684944 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 28, 2015)).
By carefully drafting and reviewing Termination With Cause clauses, in conjunction with related provisions, corporate lawyers can protect their clients' interests, ensure clear and enforceable grounds for termination, and provide a fair and balanced framework for addressing and resolving material breaches or defaults in contractual relationships.
Want to manage clauses like these effectively?
Check out Clause Library from ContractKen. It has 700+ commercial contracting clauses, with 3-4 examples for each clause available out of the box. The web interface allows easy curation, management, tagging, and commenting of clauses. Each clause example is enriched with attributes like #Times Used, Jurisdiction, Type of Contract, Party Favored, etc. And this clause library is fully accessible inside Microsoft Word, via ContractKen Word Copilot while you are reviewing or drafting contracts!
Trying to figure out how to build such a clause library from your contract repository?
ContractKen’s best-in-class contract AI can assist you to build it within days, not weeks! Get in touch to take your contract drafting to the next level!